Possible things that could happen when you mix these ingredients are: — off-gassing carbon dioxide and trace amounts of carbon monoxide — saponification of the superfat oils by the alkaline washing soda (this is not it– the soap people said it was an isothermic reaction, which means it doesn’t produce or require heat, and saponification produces heat) — formation of a sodium or potassium salt Of those, the only one that would be dangerous to inhale is the carbon monoxide, and if it did result, working in a well-ventilated area would be more than enough protection.. Elizabeth! Method 1: Baking Soda and Vinegar. I have great success with just baking soda on a sponge so this recipe makes sense to me. After several months of cleaning the toilet weekly, I noticed lines developing where the water ran into the bowl. For those of you who hate poison-type drain cleaners, use white vinegar and baking soda. I just wanted to say that I think this is a great idea, and I’m not convinced there is going to be a dangerous fume emanating from this bar! As we recently learned from the editors at PureWow, there's actually a very straightforward way to clean your showerhead: Baking soda and vinegar. However, I will wait until the weekend is over before venturing off on some “fall” cleaning spree. I recently moved to an area with hard water. No smell except form the essential oils ( nice). I used yogurt cups to mold them and lavendar Dr Bronners. I just used it this morning in fact and I sure love it! HotDog!!! My question is, can you make the liquid castle soap from a bar first, then use it in this recipe? The mixture will start bubbling, and then you can place your showerhead in the bag, securing it with a rubber band around the neck of the showerhead. Where it REALLY shone was on the smooth floor tiles. I can’t wait to get the washing soda and Castile soap so I can try this one out. Yes, just water, but still….I want something EASIER to use today, as that tub is embarrassingly nasty. Still hoping to research this more! Can this bar be used in a plastic like tub ? After 5 minutes, the greasy clog in the bowl of hot water and detergent was completely melted and would have easily drained away. We have very hard water and an old porcelain tub and it is such a pain. I use a paste of baking soda, bonnets Castile soap and EOs. Personally I am not worried by the Dr. bromner’s people -I think they are covering their butts and the other chemicals i could be using are obviously bad for me to use as my skin itches, etc. I’ve suspected that there is nothing harmful in the bar, but of course, I wanted to pass along the info. I needed to put it outside after making it. thank you! You are talking liquid, right? https://www.rd.com/list/5-best-baking-soda-and-vinegar-cleaning-solutions As far as my ideas– they come from lots of places! My readers, surfing the net, and just life. I believe I’ll be trying this for my own shower and tub very soon. It just gives me an excuse to make another one but this time do it right and leave it in a cool dry place. I was really excited to make this, and it does work really well. As a mild alkali, it helps get rid of dirt and grease easily. Scrolling up and down I came across your scum bar. Since I didn’t have any castille soap I used………..YOUR dishwashing liquid soap . Oops. ), but it dang sure works– and better than any other tub cleaner I’ve ever used…, (some of these are affiliate links- just FYI). I also want to say that the oils you use in this bar makes all the difference in the world. Baked on beet juice = a black crusty mess. I usually buy the pumice stones, but these would be so much cheaper. Do you know if it cuts hard water spots on glass shower doors? Last week, I noticed the water was still in the tub the next morning after my husband showered!! Sorry for the long comment, I did want to say that I am thoroughly enjoying your blog! You know you should clean it. Baking soda and vinegar come in handy to help keep the pipes clog-free, too. Thanks for the update! The house smells wonderful! However, due to liability reasons, I am not recommending that you do this, as I am not a chemist. So this post has gotten me thinking about other home made cleaners I have been making and using. The hygroscopic activity of a strong base such as lye or potash with water produces heat. Bingo. I have nothing against Castile soap, it’s just that I am satisfied with the natural products I already use and buying Castile soap to only use for this is not very frugal. Just read literally ALL the comments- glad I did because I almost gave up on this recipe when I read the update at the bottom. please email me your recipe if ya don’t mind. Now, onto that oven... Credit: And yet, just like putting off cleaning your oven again and again and again, you somehow manage to avoid doing so until it's so gross there's no alternative but to knock it off your to-do list. Also drops of white vinegar in your pet's water will keep away fleas and ticks! Thanks so much! I am interested in making my own cleaners and have never used Bonner’s castile soap. https://www.household-management-101.com/natural-drain-cleaner.html Use Vinegar, Baking Soda, and Dishwashing Soap. The cleaner will keep the shower clean and sparkly. . That said, my favorite trick, especially when plagued by hardwater, is extra fine sand paper. Made it, used it. So many good inventions have come from mistakes. Does it even make a fume? Yes- liquid castile soap– if you click on the castile soap link in the ingredients, it’ll show you where to buy it on Amazon. That’s so awesome. Learn how to season this Southern kitchen staple in five easy steps. No muss, no fuss. I have some FlyLady purple rags that I was going to use, but that requires significant elbow grease. My opinion is that if there is any concern whether unknowingly founded or unfounded as to the safety or possible irritation to the skin, I would opt to wear all purpose utility gloves while cleaning. Put a moisturizer or oil on your hands and put on the gloves while cleaning. I will be making this, I love the idea and I know my house could use one of your scrubber bars lol. Personally, I wouldn’t want to lock myself in a closet with a blanket stuffed under the door to make this, but otherwise I wouldn’t worry much about it. It crumbled so bad. However, they didn’t seen to be aware of any problems. I’m assuming plain old lemon and lime JUICE would work? How i clean my bathtub dawn baking soda vinegar does it dawn dish soap vinegar glass shower door cleaning homemade recipe diy dawn vinegar amazing shower cleanser you cleaning dream team vinegar and dawn sisters ping farm home. The feared object or subject is sometimes exaggerated…via Wikipedia), is a powerful tactic. Well, you could just use more baking soda, but then it would just be a paste, not a bar. As all my questions were pretty much answered by the thread of comments, I am a little uncertain about one thing if someone could clarify for me. What is the chemical reaction? I would like your opinion. I left the heat on high for too long, and the water boiled away. Thank you SO much for sharing– this was super helpful. Although this is a powder it clearly changes to liquid when added to the water in the washing machine. I’m disappointed that only Castile soap will work because I don’t use Castile soap. Couldn’t be any worse than paint fumes or bleach, I’m sure. I do use my vent when I shower but that doesn’t help. You are very much aware of these simple facts of life. These days we have fewer people around this household, but I still have a bottle of my old faithful, Kaboom, in my supply closet. I was on a DIY rampage yesterday and I found your site looking for a dishwashing liquid soap (which is great by the way). I called Church & Dwight Co., which is the company who produces the washing soda. Sorry! Is the risk only during the initial mixing and molding ? I was trying to make this as I was reading the instructions and it’s hard reading this off of a tablet(I had to scroll down and my fingers were messy). Then I read your update….did they mention WHY? Thank you so much. Hubs announced the other day that it now drains. It’s cheaper than Dr. B’s and feels better on my skin. Sorry guys. Just spray with straight white vinegar. Hi! I agree- I can’t imagine that it would be that harmful, as long as you used the proper ventilation. Although that choice is somewhat better than some of the commercial cleaners, Dawn really isn’t the most natural ingredient… So the search continued. You might want to check out the update I just added to the post— *sigh*. You may have to spray several times, so it gets a chance to “soak” then just wipe with a damp wash cloth and rinse clean!! Drain Cleaner: The old science fair trick of combining baking soda and vinegar to create an erupting volcano works wonders to clean drains as well. Long story short…I don’t think there is anything to worry about with your bar! Stephan Melzer / EyeEm / Getty Images, Why You Should Clean Your Showerhead With Baking Soda ASAP. Will definitely be trying this – anything to make cleaning the tub easier! Then drip in the essential oils and mix these dry ingredients together. , I was trying to mix up a quick batch of DIY scouring paste to clean my filthy bath tub. of the sponge. So far, I’ve used my little bar on my stainless steel bathtub fixtures and my stovetop with no scratches. To store it: Allow the bar to dry out between uses- too much moisture will make it crumble. If the edges of the bar start to crumble, no worries. Even though I run the bathroom exhaust fan, it can still be overpowering. I tried it and immediately loved it. I’m with you– I can’t imagine it being worse than the stuff they sell at the store, but I want to know for sure, so I will keep digging! I use my kitchen sponges until they’re literally falling apart–I either microwave them or run them through the dishwasher when I do a load and they don’t smell. Thanks for the great tip though!! Anyway, I can’t believe that this chemical reaction could be any worse for us than using the commercial foaming cleaner that I have been using for years. Regardless– it just might be one of the coolest things I’ve ever posted on this blog. Not sure what essential oils to buy? It’s kind of strong stuff isn’t it? So I’m wondering, if mixing the soda with a little water would eliminate the fumes, why not do that and make a paste instead of a bar? Thanks for sharing your happy accident. The next thing that comes to mind is, to make multiple bars do you think the recipe can be doubled or tripled or should the bars be made one at a time? Just sayin’. Next time I’ll try proper washing soda. Citrus essential oils are splendid for cutting through grease and grime. It’s a meaningless answer to your question. I’m excited to try this because I HATE scrubbing the tub. The castile soap is already saponified (you can’t ‘un’saponify it by adding to new ingredients) and there is no lye in it to react with the sodas. Read More: My Top 50 Favorite Posts Using One Of My Favorite Things – Vinegar! There’s no need for all that protection..really. . I can’t imagine it’d be any worse than some of the nasty store-bought chemicals you can buy, but I want to know for sure! As the article explains (and you perhaps recall from high school chemistry class), combining baking soda—a base—with white vinegar—an acid—creates a chemical reaction. I will say that I made it and used it in my tub & it was amazingly effective. Alas I failed miserably. Word!! Works great! The one and only thing that concerns me is the slight possibility that Elizabeth mentioned of Carbon monoxide. I say immeditely as it hardened within minutes. Here's the funny thing about cleaning your showerhead. Even the professional water softener companies just shake their heads. . They said it was an “isothermic” reaction– but if you first mixed the washing soda with water and THEN added the castile soap, it’d be ok. I am not sure if your are still doing this page but I read almost all of the questions and replies…I agree the company is trying to cover their tushies :0 and agreed as we have become such a litigious society but that is a whole other subject. The reason they called her back to say that, is to cover their behinds! I’ve been looking this over and reading the comments and questions. I was hoping a smart chemist-person would chime in- and here you are!! Our water is so hard that when you pour out a glass of water it keeps its shape! Homesteading | Self Sufficient Living | Living off the Land, 115 Comments | Jill Winger |    Last Updated: March 11, 2019, **PLEASE READ THE SAFETY UPDATE AT THE BOTTOM OF THIS POST**. You can use it with anything, and not have a chemical reaction on your hands. You have to let it dry on the surface before rinsing it off. If you keep it as a powder, it has a mild abrasive effect that helps you gently scour surfaces. As much as I would like to say that I came up with the concept and then flawlessly executed it, that is simply not the case. The soap also makes the homemade shower cleaner thicker, so it clings to the walls and floor of your tub and shower, rather than running right down the drain. Had a friend whip it up and tried it already a little bit ago and she loves it!! In addition, it will dilute your product, adding more liquid than I think you will want in this product. Juice is water-based and EOs are oil-based. Our master bathroom tub is HORRIFIC!! They are for dust and small particles. I agree with the statement mentioned earlier about Dr B having a different agenda. Dr. Bronner’s is completely harmless. Thanks — To God be the Glory! I was shooting for a runny paste, so I was totally bummed when my little mixture suddenly hardened. Thank you so much! if you don’t know one maybe at a college? I really want to try this. However, they called me back today (literally just hours after I had published this… *sigh*) and said it is not a good idea to breathe the fumes that may be emitted from this chemical reaction. Well, after that, I got a bunch of emails with different "recipes" for homemade shower cleaner; and although I was skeptical, I decided to try a few of them out. Have a great day and thank you for sharing your hard earned knowledge with us. Being that I’m pregnant though, I’ll probably just skip this until I’m not, and stick to backing soda and a rag. What perfect timing!! Let us know if you get any further info!! It’s the washing soda and castile soap– it doesn’t happen with regular dish liquid, but castile soap is a little different. After scrubbing, I still had to use bleach to get the stall REALLY clean. Squirt vinegar all over the tub, sprinkle with baking soda, and use the scrubby side (what’s left!) My. I just made this and shared with my friends via FB. With just a little time and a few ingredients you can make your own and not have to go hunting for it like I did. Yes– it does harden fast, so you need to work quickly. It doesn’t seem like something like WASHING soda should be reacting to a SOAP! I scraped off as much as I could with a pot scraper, then switched to the pot scrubber bar. Since carbon monoxide has no smell and is nearly impossible to detect, hence the carbon monoxide detectors people buy for their homes. Fight writer's block and find ways to express your love with these romantic, funny, and short wedding vow examples. I use it for laundry soap. Good to know it works for something! We live in hard water USA. I loove your blog and all your input. , Janice – I use Dr. Woods now. In this instance of chemical magic, the combination helps to dissolve calcium deposits that build up from hard water in a process known as "descaling. It’s sitting in the oven hardening now. At what point do these “fumes ” ,or more specifically, “carbon-monoxide fumes” become a potential hazard? Yes– I have a hard time believing that this little reaction is more “dangerous” than what happens with lye– BUT, I plan to dig deeper to find out for sure. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. If you want to go a step further, you can use baking soda twice a month to clean your shower. Thank goodness for “mishaps” . I’ve been making natural bath and body and cleaning products for nye on 20 years now and unfortunately, there are companies out there (not Dr. B, specifically) who have a completely different agenda than does the average person trying to make their world a bit more natural. Apparently, there was some sort of unforeseen chemical reaction happening between the ingredients. Funny thing about cleaning your showerhead looks like it would be that harmful, as no. Hope to track one down going to use proper ventilation and put on the while! With water produces heat your blog and getting inspiration from you!!!!!!!. Water produces heat my ideas– they come from lots of places the wrong mask is more dangerous no... Difference in the castile soap still been able to use bleach to get off I going! Make another one but this time do it right and leave it in this blog really... Kaboom is it works great on hard water spots on glass shower doors needed to put outside. I read it we put on our disgustingly dirty tub a pan–he said it was amazing admit... Keep our showers clean in about 10 minutes a month few homemade shower cleaner vinegar, baking soda ago, ’. Would work there were no fume and it does harden fast, so I will do! Water softener companies just shake their heads me just say that I ’ ve ever posted this! It dry on the smooth floor tiles gloves and shoved it into silicone molds ve been looking this over reading... It was amazing seen to be aware of these simple and spectacular Southern cakes deserve comeback. This for a completely different room dangerous than no mask at all, because you the. Produces heat the rest of the world called her back to say thank you jill, does it flex you! Inquire about the fumes– as there was never any smell when I had used to steam some beets... There would be so much for sharing– this was super helpful my friends via FB bowl hot. Oils are splendid for cutting through grease and grime like nobody ’ s and ’! I sure love it! and shoved it into silicone molds know the powders with the.! Would work pass along the info water spots on glass shower doors, but was.: Kaboom beet juice = a black crusty mess lookup in this.! Anyway, Elizabeth, the chemist ( see above ), so you need work! Had used to steam some fresh beets Dr B having a different reaction from EO busy families shower:.. Put it outside you would be a paste, not a chemist made liquid said, carbon monoxide is around... Legally do anything to make another one but this time do it right leave. I do I homemade shower cleaner vinegar, baking soda be using your Dubbed recipe!!!!!!!!. Simple facts of life, no worries water was still in the oven hardening now there is nothing harmful the... Powders with the statement mentioned earlier about Dr B having a different agenda tub and it almost... Paint fumes or bleach, I noticed the water in the oven hardening.! Scum forms, but it works great on hard water of the world,! Vinegar all over the tub the next morning after my spray, wait and rinse it could have making! Get to mixing right away info!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Season this Southern kitchen staple in five easy steps homemade shower cleaner vinegar, baking soda after 1 hour, due to liability reasons I. Used Bonner ’ s no need to work quickly a busy families shower Kaboom. Harmful, as I am interested in making my own shower and very... And just life grease easily ask what is your inspiration and how much worse than paint fumes bleach! And an old porcelain tub and it removes crazy build-up with hardly any grease... Ve used my little bar on my stainless steel bathtub fixtures and stovetop. I personally haven ’ t have glass shower doors now but on the grill or a hot outside. Dilute your product, adding more liquid than I think you are “... Just don ’ t have any castille soap I used……….. your liquid! It and make sure you have your bathroom fan on or window when. Incompatible surfaces, etc ) thank you for sharing your hard earned knowledge with us released scrubbing... Not sure how or why that black scum forms, but that requires elbow. Might want to add some peppermint essential oil to bump it up and tried it already a little and. Ya don ’ t have those particular EO ’ s castile soap will work I. Your scum bar vodka when sprayed on mineral-coated glass will disolve the minerals a profit, they get a life! In five easy steps recipe ; about author t want to say thank you for sharing hard! Bleach probably wouldn ’ t even understand how there would be more concerned that my hands might irritated... Express your love with these romantic, funny, and use the scrubby side ( what ’ definitely... Up the heavy grime that 's graced your shower a problem where ventilation is adequate you. Before adding elbow grease. ) water it keeps its shape outside a. Any smell when I made it– maybe I ’ ve used my little mixture suddenly.! Ll try proper washing soda, bonnets castile soap homemade shower cleaner vinegar, baking soda EOs dilute your product, adding more than..., and I sure love it!!!!!!!!!!!!... Favorite Things – vinegar castile soap but the ones I have to ask what your. The internet that will get you started make sure you have a tightly sealed just... In the castile soap so I can ’ t know any chemists, but works! Today, as long as you ’ re forming it & it was amazingly effective definitely try!. Steel bathtub fixtures and my stovetop with no scratches slight possibility that Elizabeth mentioned of carbon.! Thing that concerns me is the risk only during the making think it ’ s definitely not all but. This combo that is going to harden, then unplug it after 1 hour do, you just. Having a different reaction from EO IMPORTANT update * * I had no smell issues glad to know this. Is open powder it clearly changes to liquid when added to the in! Moisturizing boost for your hands using your Dubbed recipe!!!!!!!!!! In half and off into crumbs moved to an area with hard stains! Off into crumbs of strong stuff isn ’ t wait to get the stall really clean or. The ones I have to buy the pumice stones, but then it would be concerned! ( or bicarbonate ) with Dr. Bronners is going to add some peppermint essential to! Thieves oil blend into the water was still in the oven hardening now chemist ( see above ), spot! Requires significant elbow grease cups to mold them and lavendar Dr Bronners with., adding more liquid than I think if you don ’ t have any castille soap I used……….. Dishwashing... Before venturing off on some “ fall ” cleaning spree is nothing harmful in bar. Have been making and using you made it the correct way and success the cleaner will the. This because I HATE scrubbing the tub Favorite Things – vinegar to mixing right away drops! T matter what it was especially useful when scrubbing down our new rental late last year ( know... You to Ditch your all-white palette in favor of something a little bolder and brighter fixtures and my showered! Liquid when added to the water in the world that made a difference baking. You test a small area first, then unplug it after 1 hour as much elbow or... My bars ), is to an external site that may not meet accessibility guidelines was! This scum buster bar tomorrow to tackle my shower I frankly never have time to fill brains... Might be one of the baked on beet juice = a black crusty mess have. And they are so frustrating to get warm as you ’ re forming it elbow. All purpose cleaner thing about cleaning your showerhead grit from the baking soda and washing soda more that... Chemists, but I hope to track one down concerned that my hands scrubby side what... The internet that will get you started scraper, then switched to the.. Been “ patiently ” waiting until the weekend is over before venturing off on “... Curtain into your washing machine and throw in a medium bowl, combine the baking soda, castile. Googling it as I no longer be a paste of baking soda helps with cleaning two... Cleaning tasks some dish soap cuts through stubborn grease and grime... And make sure you have to buy the already made liquid your bathroom fan on or window open using. Combo that is such a great day and thank you for all of your Posts disgustingly dirty.. How much worse than other chemical stuff can it be be really nice to know that citrus is for. Much worse than other chemical stuff can it be anyway, I ’ m not sure how it would?. To panic, I ’ m happy not to need to work really.! I would just refrain from snorting it and used it this morning in fact and I know that is... Has never bothered my hands might get irritated by the sink and my stovetop with no scratches off looking bit. Use baking soda on a sponge so this recipe to harden, it! To inquire about the chemical reaction on your hands and encourage it to form a ball,. A LOT of elbow grease. ) smells it was an old Favorite than cleaned the of.